France 1999
Updated 25 April to add my comments.
On Tuesday March 2nd, France 3 held the contest to select France's song for Jerusalem, and "Je veux donner ma voix", a dramatic chanson with Celine Dion overtones, performed by Nayah, (right, pictured kindly supplied by Alex Rouffignac) was selected.
The selection was
by televote plus an in-studio jury with Gibert Becaud, Richard
Cocciante, Marie Myriam, and others, but no votes were announced,
nor placings beyond first.
Gibert Becaud
read out the result.
Marie Myriam briefly sang her 1977 winning song in German during the show, when interviewed in the audience by the presenter, Julien Lepers.
The show was fairly well done, and the audience in the vast Olympia lapped it up, but many of the songs were rather amatuerish, but that's just my (Geoff Harrison) view. You can read my comments on each song below.
There was some suggestion Nayah might have had to be pulled out, as she belongs to an illegal organisation, but it seems that she will be singing in Jerusalem.
Alex Rouffignac reports
(2 March):
The winner of
the french selection "Eurovision 99 : la selection"
is NAYAH
with the song "Je veux donner ma voix".
The song can be
discribed as a classical french ballad. It doesn't sound to much old
fashioned and sometimes reminds me of Jean Jacques Goldman's
songs for Celine Dion, but for a very short
time unfortunately.
The voice is
nearly good and strong, but the song ends with a very high note, and
she had problems to perform it both in the selection and in the
reprise of the song.
She was wearing
a dress from the famous Christian Lacroix, and
seems to have the same hairdresser as Jill Johnsson
last year. (I
think this
a joke! :GH)
The general
level of the songs were quite low, but nethertheless higher than the
one of the French selections in the 80's.
Some of the
singers didn't know very well how to sing and some performances were
really ridiculous. Amina was not in the 10
members jury,as it was planned; does it mean she is somewhere near
Sarajevo ? Only the winner was announced, no votes, no placings.
Thanks very much, Alex!
Click here to jump to the list of songs.
France 3 text: A
live broadcast from Olympia presented by Julien Lepers
(right) - France 3 brings the selection of the artist who will
represent France in the Eurovision Song Contest 1999. For the first
time the televiewers will vote live to choose from among 10
candidates selected by professionals the song and singers who will
represent France in the Eurovision Song Contest 1999 in Israel.
Throughout the
evening, extracts from the Eurovision Song Contest will recall the
history, the memory and the emotion of those great past contests.
# |
Title |
Singer(s) |
Geoff Harrison comments: |
1 |
Les droits de l'âme |
Alex |
Hey, is this the Portuguese contest? - Dark haired girl sings with backing from drums & bagpipes |
2 |
Euroland |
Karine Trécy |
Fast rubbish from young Karine who sings of 'Urroland' |
3 |
Douce |
Caractère (a boy band) |
Five black guys with no idea about melody |
4 |
C'est souvent ça, l'amour |
Nathalie Marine |
Blond girl with a deep voice and little talent |
5 |
Plus jamais, never more |
Pedro Alvez |
Fairly passable ballad from Spanish-looking Pedro who sports a little beard & moustache, and can sing |
6 |
Go ahead |
Anath |
Dark-haired girl in a strange song which was by turns slow and then fast in the 'Go ahead' bits. Not great |
7 |
Irradaka |
Kukumiku |
Whatever this was, it wasn't in French, and had an inaudible accordion. Wish the rest was similar |
8 |
La même histoire |
Ginie Line |
Vaguely motown feel to this fast song |
9 |
Gazoline |
Mo & la Gazo (a reggae song) |
Some sort of Creole effort. Dreadful to my ears |
10 |
Je veux donner ma voix |
Nayah (Winner) |
Nayah can sing, has some prescence, and the song has emotion & melody. In this company, an obvious winner, but the terrible costume has to go! |
11 |
Ihtidael |
Israhn (not in French!) |
Lots of wailing, not much lyrics or melody |
12 |
Eurosong |
Uni.T |
Two girls, two boys, crazy clothes. Lively. Could've been good, but turned out second-rate. |
Earlier info:
Alex Rouffignac reports (7 Feb) on a surprise for 1999, a French National Final:
It has been anounced yesterday evening on the private channel Canal +, that France 3 (that will broadcast the ESC this year instead of france 2) planes to choose the french entry for ESC 99 in a television programme on March the 2nd. The song would be choosen by a jury, not by televoting.
Nothing was said about the possible entries in this selection, the very first one since 1987.
Thanks, Alex!
If you know more, please e-mail me, Geoff Harrison at my contact page